Boro’s Three Most Underrated Players This Season

If you were to ask Middlesbrough fans for their Player of the Season votes, during this period of no football, one would imagine that votes would be split.

Players such as Ashley Fletcher and Daniel Ayala would each get nominations, with Paddy McNair possibly gaining a number of votes for his early season displays.

Signing Ashley Fletcher from Manchester United for £1m and selling ...
Ashley Fletcher is Middlesbrough’s top scorer with ten goals in all competitions

The top two players, however, would undoubtedly be Hayden Coulson. The Newcastle-born flanker gave a new lease of life to the side when he was first given his starting berth against Luton Town in the 2019/20 season debut, but he may take home the Young Player of the Season award – behind Jonny Howson.

Howson would be the choice of most for Middlesbrough’s Player of the Season award, regularly putting in a top shift, whether it is in midfield, out wide or in defence.

Jonny Howson Close To Signing New Middlesbrough Deal
Jonny Howson has excelled this season, which could be his last on Teesside

The season as a whole, however, has been a disapointment, with inconsistency and an inability to see games out plaguing the whole season for Jonathan Woodgate’s inaugural year incharge of his home-town club.

Some players did play well this year, though, despite the public perception by the fans or media. detail the performances of players all across Europe, and here are three Middlesbrough players who they think are underrated, and whose grades outweigh where Boro fans may see them.

3. Marvin Johnson

The arrival of Marvin Johnson in the Summer of 2017 seemed to epitomise the Garry Monk regieme, as the former Leeds United boss splashed £2 million on the Oxford United winger.

Jonathan Woodgate pleased with Marvin Johnson's impact | The ...
Marvin Johnson has one goal and two assists for Middlesbrough, this season

Johnson flattered to deceive under the manager who brought him to the club, and was subsequently loaned out the following season.

He has, however, carved a role out for himself under Woodgate’s reign and could be set to be given a contract extension in the summer.

Marvin Johnson wants a new contract with Middlesbrough | The ...
Marvin Johnson (R) battling with former Boro man, Stewart Downing during the clash between Middlesbrough and Blackburn in February

According to, Johnson averaged a 6.76 (out of ten) rating across his 29 appearances this season, which is the 11th best out of the whole squad.

Johnson excelled most, this season, in the two game stretch against Birmingham and Blackburn at home, where he grabbed one of his two assists this season in the first match, and won the Man of the Match award. Across the season, he averaged 1.3 key passes and 1.5 tackles per game.

2. Marcus Tavernier

Marcus Tavernier has always been one of the biggest hopes from Boro’s academy over recent years, ever since bursting onto the scene in 2017 with the winning goal against rivals Sunderland.

One of the main gripes that fans had with Tony Pulis, last season, was his resistance towards playing Tavernier more regularly, when it was clear that the Leeds-born midfielder was a better attacking option than the players that the Welsh coach had spent millions of pounds on.

Tavernier was given the number 7 shirt by Woodgate before the start of this season, signifying the importance that the young manager has in his player.

Perhaps Tavernier has not quite lived up to the expectation in many fans eyes, as he came in for criticism from fans on social media, on BBC Tees and in the terraces.

Tony Pulis says Middlesbrough have a pre-season decision to make ...
Tony Pulis was manager of Middlesbrough from December 2017 to May 2019 awarded Tavernier the 5th highest rating of all Middlesbrough players this season, with his 6.89 grade only behind Ravel Morrison’s 6.90, in fourth place, coming across two matches.

Tavernier recorded two goals and four assists in 29 games this season, whilst also averaging two shots per game and completing 76.7% of his passes.

The importance of 'fantastic' Marcus Tavernier is talked up by his ...
Marcus Tavernier celebrates his goal against Hull City with Ashley Fletcher

He was also recorded as playing in eight different positions in the 2019/20 season, with his stand out performances in the left winger role, away to Swansea, and Right Attacking Midfield role, coming over four matches.

Fans who have seen Tavernier play know that he prefers to play a central role, even if this means leaving his wide position vacant. Perhaps this time may be used best, for both Woodgate and Tavernier, to decide where he would be best or most effective.

1. Ryan Shotton

Surprisingly, to myself at least, Ryan Shotton is the joint highest graded player for Middlesbrough this season – sharing his 6.92 rating with Daniel Ayala, 0.01 ahead of Jonny Howson in third and 0.03 ahead of the fifth placed Tavernier.

Shotton was the last of Monk’s additions in the summer window, and subsequently his last before the now Sheffield Wednesday boss was fired following a win at Hillsborough in December 2017.

Leeds United fans defend Patrick Bamford over Middlesbrough chance ...
Ryan Shotton (L) goes in for a tackle against Patrick Bamford during the game between Leeds and Middlesbrough

The former Stoke and Birmingham defender’s signing didn’t blow fans away like those of Britt Assombalonga and Martin Braithwaite had just weeks prior. Like the aformentioned Johnson, Shotton often has his critics in the stands at the Riverside Stadium.

This season, however, he has won an average of three aerial duels per match, won over two tackles and recorded nearly four clearances per 90 minutes across his 19 appearances.

Middlesbrough FC news: Ryan Shotton opens up on left-back ...
Ryan Shotton has featured 19 times this season for Jonathan Woodgate’s side

Shotton, who also notched up 1.5 interceptions and 1.1 blocks a game – along with being admonished four times, is out of contract at the end of June.

This could affect Boro this season, depending on what happens post-lockdown, but Woodgate will be currently debating if the Pulis favourite deserves to have his contract renewed.

Report: Leeds still keen to sign Daniel Ayala during the summer
Daniel Ayala hasn’t played since January 1st for Middlesbrough, due to injury

According to, Shotton is currently the tenth highest earner at the club, on £15,000. His teammate and the other player to earn a 6.92 rating for Boro, Ayala also has his contract up in June. state that the Spaniard takes home £25,000 per week.

If it came down to pinching the pennies next season, it may make more sense for Steve Gibson to choose to renew Shotton over Ayala if the stats say they have performed similarly this season.

Jonathan Woodgate admits to contract concerns at Middlesbrough ...
Ryan Shotton celebrates Daniel Ayala’s goal against Bristol City

Who would be your pick for Boro’s player of the season! Let us know on Twitter, Facebook or Instagram!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s